Found this on a website http://www.usgennet.org/usa/wi/county/richland/books/chap26.htm
Lodges.
Ithaca Lodge, No. 93, IOOF, at Sextonville, was instituted June 25, 1857, by David H Wright, grand master of Madison. The charter members were as follows: S Bailey, B W Telfair, Albert Ghastin, M Britton, N A Hawks and J E Irish. The first officers, elected were as follows: J E Irish, noble grand; B W Telfair, vice grand; M Britton, recording secretary; and Albert Ghastin, treasurer. The following, named in order, have served as noble grand of the lodge; B W Telfair, S Bailey, George Richards, George Krouskop, Lemuel Akey, A Ghastin, D Williams, L D Hall, William McCorkle, D L Hubbard, J B Grew, T P Derrickson, Amasa Grover, H W Glasier, L A Taylor, J Knapp, John Jaquish, D P Nichols, William Krouskop, H H Barnard, F B Hubbard, James D Keys, John Kuykendall, F D Fowler, J L R McCollum, J H Post, A Ghastin, J Knapp, William Krouskop, J G Lamberson, Alfred Kuykendall, Henry R Howard, A M Stratten, G N Hill, Jacob Hoover, J S Stofer, George Parker, D B Ostrander, Clayton Bush, L C Taylor, George M Hoke, J L R McCollum, D B Ostrander, G M Hoke, E E Ostrander, A H Dowe, R Gibbens, David Warner, J W Parker, E Parker, D A Barnard and J Warner. The officers of the lodge, in 1883, were as follows: J Warner, NG; F W Turner, VG; W A Reed, RS; J D Keys, treasurer. At the present time there are thirty-three members, and the lodge is in good working condition.